NY Pizza Suprema Menu
NY Pizza Suprema, located in the heart of NYC, is a renowned pizza joint offering a wide variety of mouth-watering pies and slices. Their award-winning NYC Round Cheese Pizza and Upside Down Pizza are must-tries, featuring fresh ingredients and delicious flavors. With options like Margarita Pizza, White Pizza with Garlic, and Grandma Pizza, there's something for every pizza lover. The casual, no-frills atmosphere adds to the authentic New York experience. Customers rave about the fast service and ample seating, making it a convenient choice for a quick and satisfying meal. While prices may be on the higher side, the quality and taste of the pizzas make it worth every penny. If you're looking for a slice of New York's pizza culture, NY Pizza Suprema is the place to be.
Our Famous Signature Pizza Pies
NYC Round Cheese Pizza
8 slices. Award-winning! Famed for receiving the only perfect score by the slice Harvester who sampled over 375 slices in Manhattan. Our famous signature pizza with a light delicious thin crust slightly charred topped with our famous homemade tomato sauce and imported pecorino Romano cheese and finest grande mozzarella.
Margarita Pizza
A thin hand-tossed crust is topped with a fresh homemade pomodoro sauce. The fresh mozzarella is placed in between and sprinkled on top, is a generous layer of imported pecorino Romano cheese. The pie is finished off with a light drizzling of imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, its finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
White Pizza with Garlic
No red sauce. A thin white slice topped with generous dollops of the finest whipped creamiest ricotta and finished with a sprinkling of imported pecorino Romano, fresh garlic and a drizzle of imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, its finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
New York Style Sicilian Pizza
12 slices. A deep dish crust light and airy with our homemade savory tomato sauce, sprinkled with imported pecorino Romano, fresh basil and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy covered with our finest grande mozzarella. Post bake, its finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Upside Down Pizza
12 slices. A sauce lover's favorite. The finest grande mozzarella covers light and airy deep-dish square crust. The mozzarella is covered with our homemade cooked onion-based sauce. Then finished with imported pecorino Romano cheese and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy with a tossing of fresh basil. Post bake, its finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Marinara Pizza
12 slices. Delicious garlic-based marinara sauce, sprinkled with imported pecorino Romano cheese and finished with fresh basil.
Grandma Pizza
9 slices. On a thin crust, pan baked is a fresh plum tomato sauce, imported pecorino Romano, fresh mozzarella. Post baked, finished off with fresh basil and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
NYC Round Cheese Pizza Slice
Our famous signature pizza with a light delicious thin crust slightly charred, topped with our famous homemade tomato sauce and imported pecorino Romano cheese and finest grande mozzarella.
New York Style Sicilian Pizza Slice
A deep dish crust light and airy with our homemade cooked onion base sauce, sprinkled with imported pecorino Romano, fresh basil and imported extra-virgin olive oil from Italy covered with our finest grande mozzarella.
Burrata Specialty Pizza
Our signature pizza with our slightly charred light delicious thin crust, topped with our homemade tomato sauce, imported pecorino Romano, grande mozzarella, with dollops of burrata cheese, a touch of fresh basil and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, its finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Hot Honey Specialty Pizza
A round pie with light dollops of fresh ricotta, fresh mushrooms, our finest grande mozzarella. Post-baked, finished with hot pepper-infused honey. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Fig Specialty Pizza
A round pie topped off with the finest grande mozzarella, creamy goat cheese, fig spread, premium bacon, imported pecorino Romano, fresh basil and Imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Chicken BBQ Specialty Pizza
A thin hand-tossed crust is topped with a premium grande mozzarella lightly breaded white meat chicken cutlet, imported pecorino Romano cheese and homemade BBQ sauce, with a touch of fresh minced garlic. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Chicken Parmigiana Specialty Pizza
Our famous round pie topped with lightly breaded white meat chicken cutlet, imported pecorino Romano cheese, and the finest grande mozzarella cheese finished off with fresh basil. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Specialty Pizza
Fresh white meat chicken cutlet, crispy bacon, fresh jalapenos, sauteed onions, and our finest grande mozzarella, with a sprinkling of imported pecorino Romano on a thin crust, finished off with a creamy ranch dressing. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza
Our famous round pie topped off with a delicious tender white meat Buffalo chicken. Covered with Buffalo chicken sauce. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano. No substitutions.
Suprema Specialty Pizza
Our namesake round pie with our homemade tomato sauce, imported pecorino Romano, grande mozzarella, topped with all the favorites: fine sweet Italian sausage, imported Italian pepperoni sauteed sliced onions, fresh roasted red peppers and fresh mushrooms. Finished with fresh basil. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano. No substitutions.
Meat Lover's Specialty Pizza
Our round pie is topped off with Boar Head's ham, sweet Italian sausage, imported pepperoni and crushed Italian meatballs. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano. No substitutions.
Hawaiian Specialty Pizza
Our round pie topped with our homemade tomato sauce, finest grande mozzarella, fresh pineapples and Boar Head's ham. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Pepperoni Fra Diavolo Specialty Pizza
We start off with a light and airy Sicilian-style crust. Topped with our finest grande mozzarella. Our fresh homemade fra diavolo sauce and finished with our imported spicy pepperoni from Italy.
1/2 and 1/2 Specialty Pizza
Choice of 2 specialty pizzas on each half.
Cheese Lover's Pizza
With combination of the finest cheese, Grande mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, ricotta and Romano cheeses.
Chicken Parmigiana and Bruschetta Pizza
Chicken Parmesan pizza topped with diced fresh tomatoes, onions and fresh basil.
Chicken and Broccoli Pizza
Topped with lightly breaded Perdue white meat chicken cutlet and broccoli.
Hot Honey Pizza Slice
The same great grandma pie topped with fresh mushrooms, Our round pie with light dollops of fresh ricotta, fresh mushrooms, our finest grande mozzarella. Post baked, finished with a hot pepper infused honey.
Jalapeno Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
The same great chicken Parmesan pizza topped with fresh sliced jalapenos and sauteed onions.
Meat Lover's Pizza Slice
Our round pie is topped off with Boar Heads ham, sweet Italian sausage, imported pepperoni and crushed Italian meatballs.
Suprema Pizza Slice
Our namesake round pie with our homemade tomato sauce, imported pecorino Romano, grande mozzarella, topped with all the favorites: fine sweet Italian sausage, imported Italian pepperoni, sauteed sliced onions, fresh roasted red peppers and fresh mushrooms. Finished with fresh basil. No substitutions.
Veggie Lover's Pizza
Topped with spinach, broccoli, onions peppers and fresh mushrooms. Has cheese, no substitutions.
Veggie Medley- A Vegan Friendly Pizza
12 slices. On a light airy Sicilian crust, diced fresh tomatoes, black olives, onions and fresh mushrooms that are sauteed with fresh garlic in imported extra virgin olive oil. No cheese and no substitutions.
White Eggplant Pizza
White pie topped with lightly breaded eggplant cutlets. No sauce.
Our Specialty Pizza Pies
Vegetable and Vegan Pizza
The New York Vegan Regular Slice Pizza
A savory delicious pizza sauce. Topped with a nondairy and soy-free shredded vegan mozzarella cheese. Finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy and fresh basil. Contains nuts. Vegan.
The Vegan Alfredo Pizza
A vegan pizza made with our homemade Macadamia Alfredo truffle sauce, vegan mozzarella cheese, spinach and sauteed sliced onions. Contains nuts. Vegan.
Vegan Margarita Pizza
A thin crust pie with a non dairy and soy-free vegan mozzarella cheese made with natural coconut, topped with generous dollops of fresh plum tomato sauce. Finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy, oregano and fresh basil. Contains nuts. Vegan.
Vegan Grandma Pizza
A thin-crust pie with a non dairy and soy-free vegan mozzarella cheese made with natural coconut. Topped with fresh mushrooms, sauteed sliced onions, roasted red peppers. Post baked, finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy, oregano and fresh basil. Contains nuts. Vegan.
Vegan White - with Garlic and Cashew Ricotta Pizza
A non dairy and soy-free vegan mozzarella cheese made from natural coconut. Topped with dollops of our homemade creamy cashew ricotta cheese, a sprinkling of fresh garlic. Then we finished off with our imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Vegan.
Vegan Upside Down Pizza
A light and airy deep dish crust topped with vegan mozzarella made from coconut covered with our homemade cooked onion based tomato sauce. Finished with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy and oregano. Vegan.
Vegan New York Style Sicilian Pizza
A light and airy deep dish crust with our homemade savory tomato sauce topped with vegan mozzarella made from coconut and finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Vegan.
Spinach Dip Pizza
A round thin crust topped with grande mozzarella, pecorino Romano and a secret homemade white sauce fresh spinach dip recipe. Post baked, finished off with a imported Parmesan cheese from Italy.
Fresh Baked Eggplant Pizza
Our thin-crust with a delicious pre-cooked onion base tomato sauce. Topped with thinly sliced home-baked eggplant and a premium grande mozzarella. Finished with a little sprinkling of fresh garlic, imported pecorino Romano, imported Parmigiano-Reggiano and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy.
Vegan Veggie Lover's Pizza
Our round pie is topped with spinach, zucchini, eggplant, sliced onions, red peppers, fresh mushrooms, with vegan mozzarella made from coconut and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy.
Margherita Primavera Pizza
A round thin crust topped with homemade fresh mozzarella, a delicious Pomodoro sauce, grilled vegetables (eggplant, zucchini and tricolor peppers) post baked, finished off with a generous sprinkling of imported Parmesan cheese, imported pecorino Romano, imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy and fresh basil.
Vegan White Truffle with Spinach
An organic nut free, soy free, artisanal vegan truffle ash brie "cheese" non-dairy pie. Topped with a secret creamy vegan sauce, vegan ash brie, sauteed onions and imported extra-virgin olive oil from Italy.
2 Liter Bottled Soda
Beverages
Calzones and Rolls (Archived)
Calzone
Imported romano and the finest ricotta and grande mozzarella cheeses.
Sausage Roll
Sausage, onions, peppers, romano and grande mozzarella cheeses. No sauce.
Meatball Roll
Our famous onion based cooked sauce - meatballs, imported romano and grande mozzarella cheeses.
Chicken Parmigiana Roll
Our famous onion based cooked sauce - lightly breaded white meat chicken cutlet imported romano and grande mozzarella cheeses.
Eggplant Parmigiana Roll
Onion-based sauce - lightly breaded eggplant, romano, ricotta & grande mozzarella cheeses.
Broccoli Roll
Broccoli, light garlic, with ricotta and Grande mozzarella cheeses.
Spinach Roll
Spinach, light garlic, with ricotta and Grande mozzarella cheeses.
